This is arguably the most crucial part of the directing process and, if done wrong, can result in a lot of time spent putting on the wrong show. There are two main aspects to consider when choosing a play: practical and creative.
Practical
The practical side of choosing a play ultimately boils down to finding a play you can actually put on. Often there’re lots of plays people want to put on, but there are many steps and checkpoints a show needs to pass before you can even consider staging it.
The biggest hurdle is going to be whether the rights are available. Often you can work this out by typing the play title into Google and searching around - you’ll soon find if there are rights you need to get, and where to get them from. (It’s worth noting that plays where it’s been over 70 years since the author’s death are free to put on without rights – this includes all original Greek plays, Shakespeare, Chekhov and so on, but be careful about paying for rights to stage a translation).
A good place to begin looking is Concord Theatricals or, for musicals, MTI.co.uk (make sure you go to the UK site!). These websites will give you a list of shows that these companies hold the rights to, as well as how to apply for these rights.
Other practical things to think about when choosing a show include:
Budget – can you do this play on the budget you’ll be working with?
Space – what stage spaces are available to you in Oxford?
Children – the only shows I know that have been able to bring children into the cast are shows in the Oxford Playhouse, and even then this involves chaperones and DBS checks and so on. It is also usually limited to 1-2 children in a couple of scenes, as you can’t rehearse a young company as intensely as you do students (you might have them for 2-3 hours every Sunday, for example).
Size of cast – how many company members can you fit in the venue you’re aiming for (think not only about stage space but also dressing room space etc)
Some of the above can be manoeuvred around by creative choices, but they’re worth thinking about as early on as possible.
Creative
This is an aspect of choosing a show that took me a very long time to get right and it is really important to think about right at the start. I used to pick shows because they were fun, popular and I’d seen them staged myself. This method of choosing completely failed me when I tried to stage a show that I realised I loved to watch, but I had nothing to say about it myself. Every design meeting I went to I plucked ideas out of thin air without much reasoning behind it – and rehearsals weren’t any better.
Before you even think about putting on a show, get your hands on the script (don’t settle for having watched the film or a bootleg on YouTube), read it all the way through and if your mind isn’t buzzing with creative ideas, either read it again or forget staging it.
What you want is a connection to the piece. A feeling that you, and only you should be putting it on, and that you have a very specific part of the story you want to bring out in your staging. As the director, you’re in charge of picking out certain elements of the story for the audience to see – so the sooner you know what these are, the easier the rest of the process will be. (All of this is particularly true for things like Greek and Shakespeare plays that have been staged many times over, original plays/new writing have slightly more flexibility in terms of original creative vision.)
A good place to start with choosing a play is to either start by looking through websites and recommendations for shows you can put on, or to think about what kind of a show you’d like to stage and then find one to fit that. E.g if you want to stage a show with a strong female focus in the story search around for plays that explore that.
Another thing that I think is important to consider at this stage is your audience and why they should come and see this show, particularly as that will shape your marketing plan and it will almost definitely be a question asked in bid interviews. Some shows are great, but if you don’t think a largely student audience (or any other audience you think you can target) will want to see it, either save that for post-uni times or find a way to make it relevant for that audience.
Finally, as a word of caution, make sure you’re putting on a show that you’ve thoroughly checked has aged well. You don’t want to get to the rehearsal point of a show and realise there’s previously undiscovered racism, sexism and so on in the text that you have to work around. (I think this is more of a thing in musicals than in plays, but just be aware of it!).